In alphabetical order, these are the top four names. Still can't narrow it down to just one! Also, we're having trouble with good middle names and nicknames. "Ann" would be good as a middle name for many of our top choices, but that is already Betsy's middle name. Suggestions welcome.
Amy Josephine (nickname: Amy Jo)
Audrey (middle name? nickname?)
Eleanor (middle name? nicknames: Ella, Nora)
Natalie (middle name? nickname?)